President Donald Trump speaks during a meeting with Navajo code talkers on Monday at the White House.
Susan Walsh, The Associated Press
President Donald Trump speaks during a meeting with Navajo code talkers on Monday at the White House.

President Donald Trump name-called Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., “Pocahontas” at an event honoring Navajo code talkers, all under a portrait of Trail of Tears orchestrator Andrew Jackson. It reads like a case study in offensiveness, and still some people don’t seem to get it.

Eric Trump’s Tuesday tweet sums up the stupidity best:

What’s really staggering is Eric Trump’s inability to tell the difference between a movie depicting a historical figure and his father transforming that figure’s name into a put-down of a political opponent.

Neither the president nor his son may know Pocahontas as anything but a cartoon, but as Navajo Nation President Russell Begaye put it, “Pocahontas is a real person. It’s not a caricature.” She was the daughter of a Powhatan chief in colonial Virginia who allegedly rescued one English captain and was later held hostage by another.

Trump’s repeated reference to “Pocahontas” is racist first of all because it’s intended as a pejorative. Trump does not like Warren. It’s also racist because it seizes on a stereotypical Native American name to refer to an entire race — like calling an Asian man “Jackie Chan” or a black man “Frederick Douglass” (one of the president’s favorites).

Worse yet, Trump is mushing together his tribes: At an event to honor Navajo heroes, he used the name of a Powhatan woman to disparage a senator who claimed Cherokee ancestry.

And that cuts to the argument that has taken over conservative Twitter in the past two days. Never mind what Trump did, defenders say. What Warren did was worse.

“I think what most people find offensive is Senator Warren lying about her heritage to advance her career,” said Sarah Huckabee Sanders in a White House news conference on Monday, sparking the relitigation of a so-called scandal during Warren’s 2012 Senate run. Warren had listed herself as a minority in an Association of American Law Schools directory, and Harvard Law School had pointed to her as a Native American member of an otherwise non-diverse faculty.

Was it true? Warren said yes. A progressive advocate said maybe, and just 1/32nd. The tribe Warren claimed to belong to would probably have said no: She was not a member of the Cherokee Nation, or the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians or the United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee. That teeny, tiny bit of unsubstantiated ancestry wouldn’t have qualified her to join.

Warren comes from Oklahoma, where many white Americans reportedly believe they have Cherokee blood. She could never point to a specific ancestor and talked about the “high cheekbones” of some family members instead. She also noted that, though she takes pride in her “heritage,” she never used it to get ahead. This, too, was tough to fact-check.

But there’s no fact-checking necessary to know that two things can be bad at the same time. If Warren lied or even exaggerated, that’s wrong. Trump insulted the indigenous population by throwing around “Pocahontas” as a derogatory term for an imagined generic American Indian. That’s wrong, too.

A better question than whether Warren is actually Native American is whether it matters in this debate – and it doesn’t. Warren could be all Cherokee, or 1/32nd Cherokee, or not Cherokee at all, and Trump would still be using the name of one Native American woman as a slur against all Native American people. The worst of Trump’s latest dust-up with Elizabeth Warren, in other words, has nothing to do with Elizabeth Warren at all.

Molly Roberts works for The Washington Post’s opinion section. Follow her on Twitter: @mollylroberts

To send a letter to the editor about this article, submit online or check out our guidelines for how to submit by email or mail.

More in Opinion Columnists

  • 696155927 2018-01-17
  • 877540926 2018-01-17
  • 224868925 2018-01-17
  • 18998924 2018-01-17
  • 337760923 2018-01-17
  • 71525922 2018-01-17
  • 879867921 2018-01-17
  • 445959920 2018-01-17
  • 498632919 2018-01-17
  • 813538918 2018-01-17
  • 792538917 2018-01-17
  • 7613916 2018-01-17
  • 492452915 2018-01-17
  • 489763914 2018-01-17
  • 65734913 2018-01-17
  • 9516912 2018-01-17
  • 865819911 2018-01-17
  • 724582910 2018-01-17
  • 267479909 2018-01-16
  • 839568908 2018-01-16